This is a skeletal system that is designed to be both detailed and flexible; you and your colleagues will use this framework to create a unit-a course that uses all the sequential elements of the framework. It is organized to fit the timeline and expectations of Massachusetts Science & Engineering Fair so students are ‘science fair ready’ should they choose to participate. Each phase of the unit you create will build on the previous phase(s).
Downloadable teacher guide with additional resources coming soon.
Are you a student? Find resources HERE
In this initial step is designed for teachers to prepare the structure and supports that will guide students through their independent project work. This phase is about setting students up for success by doing the behind-the-scenes work: aligning the project with academic goals, ensuring it fits into existing coursework, and preparing the materials and systems that will support student-led learning. This phase includes information about rules and policies to participate in MSEF as well as resources for planning timelines, setting student expectations, and opportunities for funding.
Use this guide to understand the differences and overlap between the 4 steps to participate in a Fair, the 4 phases of project work, and the 5 required components. Download or request a copy of this classroom poster.
Process and Policies:
The Middle School Manual (grads 6-8) and the High School Manual (grades 9-12) provide a detailed overview to process and policies for Fair participation. USE THE SEARCH FUNCTION OR TABLE OF CONTENTS TO FIND THE INFORMATION YOU NEED. Email info@scifair.com with questions or for assistance.
Since the full manual can feel intimidating, you can also use the High School Science Fair Ready Checklist (5 pages) or the Middle School FAQs (3 pages)
Paperwork and Dates:
All Massachusetts Fairs use the zFairs system to submit projects for approval and get details for the Fair events. Go to MAMS.zfairs.com for 6-8th grade or MAHS.zfairs.com for 9-12th grade. FOLLOW THE TUTORIALS for filling out forms and updating paperwork. Email src@scifair.com with questions or for assistance.
It’s important to remember that student projects should represent their own work from the ideation to the presentation. The resources here will help student independence and foster true, open-ended inquiry. While websites like ScienceBuddies.com and Teachers Pay Teachers offer ideas and resources, buying a project or copying one that’s already been done defeats the purpose of the science fair. Projects should reflect original thinking and a unique approach developed by the student. Classroom labs and pre-designed experiments do not qualify as science fair projects. The goal is to explore a scientific question in a new way, using their own curiosity, creativity, and critical thinking.
Make sure you, your students, and their parents are familiar with the language in the MSEF Ethics Statement.
Setting incremental deadlines for various stages of the projects will set up students for success. Think about how that fits into your classroom schedule and assessment.
We recommend starting with ideation activities, background research, and brainstorming activities early in the school year. This is a challenging stage so more time to build curiosity gives students a leg up on deciding the focus of their project later.
Project plans should be drafted and approved by the teacher in advance of deadlines to allow time for approval and gathering project materials. During this waiting period after plans are submitted and before materials are received, students can still work on their project by creating a mock-up of their paper, continuing background research, or practicing their public speaking.
Use one or more of these resources with students:
NOTE ABOUT DEADLINES: We encourage students and teachers to set deadlines for submitting paperwork for project approval based on the work they need to complete. While there are final dates for submission of forms based on regional fair dates, students should be submitting for approval to allow time for feedback, required adjustments and avoid disqualification. Some teachers find it’s helpful to have all students on the same, earlier deadline for approval.
MSEF offers a range of resources to schools and students including mentor hours, on-demand consultations, and student events. Access to supply wishlists are based on eligibility. Sign up for the Teacher Newsletter HERE or email info@scifair.com to learn more.
Consider a community inventory of people and topics that are locally relevant. For example:
HOW TO USE RESOURCES: Most MSEF resources are available as hyperlinks – often in Google Drive. Many teachers use Google Classroom or a similar platform to organize resources for their students. We suggest downloading or using the ‘Make a Copy’ option to create your own version of the document. This will help students access the links who might have firewalls setup to external systems. Email info@scifair.com if you are having trouble accessing or adapting resources.
Use this guide to understand the differences and overlap between the 4 steps to participate in a Fair, the 4 phases of project work, and the 5 required components.
Too many terms to keep track of? Science Fair Glossary
Some teachers find that it’s useful to establish contracts with students. This can establish clear expectations on student role, teacher role, parent role and/or mentor role. See template below and adapt as appropriate.
You can also create teacher assessment or self-assessment checks at critical points of the work. Consider tying some or all of these to grades or assessment to provide accountability for students.
The culmination of the Fair experience is standing in front of a STEM professional and presenting your work. It is a benefit for students to be aware of what judges will be looking for so they know how to best spend their time, and often make the process feel more achievable. Judges are NOT looking for the most sophisticated project. They ARE looking for student understanding and thoroughness.
Review the Middle School rubric and the High School rubric to see what judges will be looking for in student projects.
Use the Checklist for Judging worksheet to periodically assess their work.
In addition to the lessons below, these planning templates and guides may be useful for your students to use throughout the steps of the process. Choose the one that works best for your classroom. Download or make a copy to your drive.
You can also use and adapt this student planning template. The template includes
The Science Fair Experiment Planning Template is recommended for students new to scientific experimentation, including Middle School students.
GUIDES:
Data from past Science Fair winners has shown that access to labs or expensive equipment does not provide an advantage. While some projects certainly benefit from access to lab equipment and resources, there are many project areas where it is not needed or appropriate. As long as you aren’t working with restricted materials that need a lab, judges appreciate and respect the ingenuity of creating materials and improvising. Students can also consider exploring data analysis, computer modeling, social science or environmental studies among many other focal areas
Teachers can explore opportunities – including those below – to provide additional support for the classroom as a whole and/or individual student projects.
Encourage a science fair culture in your classroom. We recommend using a bulletin board in the classroom or hallway as the communication hub.
Create a color-coded, visually engaging bulletin board to prominently display all critical information related to the science fair process.
Include information about Project guidelines, Report templates, Poster boards, example Presentation tips, Registration website.
You can use scannable QR codes that link directly to sites or print out MSEF resources to share. For example, slide 2 and 3 of the Project Component Guide provide an overview of the project components needed.
You can also use this bulletin board early on in the process to post interesting articles or have students share ideas or questions that can inspire future projects. Consider these prompts:
Independent student projects can be an interdisciplinary experience, combining skills from science, engineering, social studies, math, technology, and language arts. There is an opportunity for students to investigate questions or issues that are relevant to their local community. Projects allow students to experience all Mass STE Practices, in addition to math and literacy skills among others.
Each student will have a unique experience during their project, and these personal journeys are an opportunity for growth and self-discovery. Completing an independent research project can build self-confidence and provide a sense of fulfillment.
MSEF is here to help. Email us at info@scifair.com with questions, program requests, or for help in connecting with your regional representatives.
Developing a Project Focus: This phase is about building observations and curiosity to launch students to a project idea. Students will identify a question to answer or problem to solve based on their observations of the world around them. They will conduct background research and explore feasibility of the project area/idea they chose. Using systems-thinking, students narrow their focus to one aspect of the problem that they would like to investigate further. Students will determine details like individual vs group project, potential restrictions and rules, identify needed materials, and where they might need help.
MSEF suggests looking to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals and/or the National Academy of Engineering Grand Challenges to help students find project ideas. We recommend starting this work early in the school year throughout several units so students have a treasury of project ideas to choose from when project work starts.
This phase should take 1-4 weeks depending on prep work.
Students should start their work with a lab notebook. A classic composition book works well, but for shorter term projects you can use ‘blue books’ and add on if needed. While digital notebooks are currently accepted, MSEF strongly recommends using paper notebooks and handwritten notes. It is easier to show evidence and ownership of your work and, research shows, that handwriting improves comprehension. You can add printed out images or charts if needed.
All entries should be dated!
The notebook is used for
Setting up your Notebook Worksheet (coming soon)
Example notebooks (coming soon)
Link to Project Component Guide
Consider starting the unit with a high-interest entry event on one topic or several topics to help students start ideating. Entry events can be an opportunity to build community among students and, if possible, with outside resources. Science thrives through collaboration.
One idea is to set up station rotations with UN Sustainable Development Goals or National Academy of Engineering Grand Challenges. Using observational data and/or personal experiences, students articulate the problem, why the problem is important, root causes of the problem, symptoms of the problem.
Possible tools to explore
REMEMBER: Students haven’t yet decided if they will solve a problem through science research, computer science, engineering, or mathematics. They are still focused on the big idea they want to address, not the procedure for getting there.
Student Podcast: Brainstorming
Now that they have some ideas it’s time to start the background research.
Preliminary research will help them narrow down their ideas to get ready for the next phase. Ultimately, students should have at least 3 credible sources for research including journal articles and scholarly publications. Background resources should be age-appropriate. All works should be cited. Use the project notebook to record!
Once they have narrowed down their topics in the next few steps they will likely need to do more research on their chosen topic.
At this stage it’s important for the teacher and students to be familiar with rules and restrictions based on the project area they would like to pursue. We don’t want students to settle on a project idea that will not be allowed.
MSEF’s Updated AI Guidance is available HERE, as well as practical applications and examples HERE.
Students may have identified a starting place like
(1) a big idea/topic,
(2) a tool they want to use or skill they want to practice
(3) a scientific or engineering field they’re interested in
but the key to a strong project is connecting the dots between all three of these areas. Their role at this stage is to take the initial spark, the background research they started, and build it into a project that is feasible with the time, materials, and skills available.
The Building Blocks Worksheet was designed to help students connect the dots between a big idea, a skill or tool they want to use, and a procedure/area of science.
Projects should show evidence of scientific research, engineering design, computer science, or mathematics.
High School Project Categories
Middle School Project Categories
Multi-disciplinary project? Think about what type of judge would be the best fit for your project? Make sure the rubric applies to your project (i.e. engineering vs. science research). You can change your category up to a few weeks before the Regional Fairs but not between Regional and State Fairs.
Students may not have identified if they are working in a team or individually. Help connect students together who are focused on the same topic, or whose skills will compliment each other. Consider the Jigsaw Method.
Students should think about the pros and cons of working with a partner including these questions:
Once students start experimentation as a team they need to stay teammates through all competitions.
Teachers can email MSEF with questions or to discuss extenuating circumstances.
Problem statements or research questions should include who, what, when, where, and how and be worded so a number of possible solutions are attainable.
The Sentence Starters guide includes several sections of prompts that students can use to brainstorm potential sentence endings to help narrow down the scope of their project. They should use a page or two of their notebook to generate as many possibilities they can think of and then evaluate them for interest and feasibility.
Hypothesis to Conclusion:
Remember, science fair projects do not provide definitive proof. While they can play an important role in the scientific research process, their scope and applicability are often limited. As a result, hypotheses are not “proven,” but rather accepted or rejected based on the data and its analysis.
The results should not drive the project! A science fair project isn’t about proving a predetermined idea the student wants to be true. Data must never be manipulated to fit expectations. Instead, follow the procedures carefully and allow the data to reveal the outcome naturally.
Share this short student podcast for advice from other students on background research and forming a hypothesis: Student Podcast: Background Research and Hypothesis
Once students have their research question or problem statement, it is time to evaluate before moving to the next phase.
Use guiding questions for this stage
Consider –
Based on work in this phase, determine what is needed for student or classroom assistance through MSEF or others.
This can be a great opportunity for an ‘Inspiration Station’. This is an opportunity for an expert to be present in the classroom or virtually to meet with students individually or by team. STEM professionals can listen to their ideas and provide prompt, potential resources, or reminders about safety. Contact MSEF to learn more at student@scifair.com
Creating a Research Plan: In brief, Phase 2 centers around the research plan- establishing the project goal(s) and preparing for experimentation. Students create a research plan or engineering design proposal based on their project idea. The development of the plan will require students to understand their topic as well as norms in the procedure or method they would like to pursue. Plans require a risk assessment and understanding of Science Fair rules. Documenting steps of this process is key- beyond the lab notebook, you will develop a research plan/proposal that details each element of your experimental design.
Projects cannot proceed until the plans are approved by the teacher and/or the Scientific Review Committee so timelines should include a break in project work at this point.
Plan 2-3 weeks for this phase.
In order to complete this phase, students should have
Find instructions for science research or engineering design in these handbooks:
Potential resources
Start organized, stay organized.
Starting students off with a research plan template helps them understand what information they’ll need to map out their work. This will help with the work they are submitting for approval, as well as pull together information that will help them draft their final report down the line.
Organize your required sections. There are a number of Research Plan Templates available, designed for High School projects but usable for all students. Alternately, the Middle School Paperwork Packet includes the required research plan questions for submission.
This can be done digitally but students should keep track of notes and planning recorded in their project notebook.
Sections should include
Provide structure and resources based on type of project (science, engineering, computer science, or math). MSEF can help connect to available tools or STEM professionals to help.
Students should research available tools and methodology – take notes, reflect, and discuss. They should identify where they may need additional support. They should identify what set of rules they need to follow.
This reflection should cover these areas for project design:
Depending on the type of projects students are exploring, the steps to their process and materials they’ll need will vary.
It is THEIR JOB to follow the steps and process and pursue the content and context of their project. Your role as teacher is to make sure they have the framework they need to do this.
Remember to consult the following handbooks for step by step instructions:
This STEM Process Poster can also be a useful classroom resource to understand the steps needed for different projects.
Once the planning work is done in the steps above, students are ready to write their procedure. These are the steps taken to complete the project in the proper order. This is crucial to allow the experiment or design to be repeated exactly to get the same results. A well-written and thorough procedure will also make the review process MUCH easier because there will be less need clarification and conversation with SRC reviewers.
Questions students should ask themselves:
Consider having students can share the draft of their procedure with peers to test for understanding.
Not all projects are required to submit Form 3 (HS) or Form D (MS) for a formal risk assessment, we strongly encourage ALL students to conduct a risk assessment on their project.
Risk is the potential for harm—physical, emotional, environmental, or ethical—that can result from your experiment. Common types of risk include:
In planning, students should review:
In research plans, students should identify what was considered and how risk was ‘mitigated’ or avoided. Including this information -even for projects with low risk -signal to the reviewers that the plan is well thought out and the students prepared for their work.
See lesson 7 in the Science Research Handbook or lesson 7 in the Engineering Design Handbook.
Each MSEF entry is required to submit paperwork in advance of the fair to assure projects have been properly researched, designed, and supervised.
While projects in restricted areas require approval from the Statewide Scientific Review Committee before experimentation, all projects require teacher approval before proceeding. For that reason, MSEF suggests completing forms before experimentation for all projects.
If schools need accommodations to manage paperwork and approvals, please reach out to src@scifair.com in advance to coordinate.
High School Students (grades 9-12th)
Middle School Students (grades 6-8th)
Projects in restricted area must have approval before proceeding with experimentation. Please help students plan ahead to allow at least two weeks. Remember that incomplete paperwork or unclear procedures will delay approvals.
Email src@scifair.com with questions.
Deadlines:
Remember:
While students wait for approval, use the down time as an opportunity for assessment and/or preparing for the work that will come next.
Assessment and Feedback: Use the feedback prompts like those in the Student Project Planning Template for students to take part in peer-to-peer conversation, self-reflection, or teacher check-in. Have them reflect on how their project work went in the first two phases– consider both academic goals as well as social-emotional. Teams should reflect on their work together and clarify expectations.
More Background Research: Students can use this time to expand their background research and citations. For example, they can look for work in related fields to help build their understanding of the relevance and connections for their project (something judges look for!)
Preparing Project Components: Consult the Project Components Guide to see what will be needed for their project report, project display, and oral presentation. There is a lot of overlap between these three components so mapping out the information they need now will make that process faster later. See slide 3.
Practicing Oral Presentations: The more students practice throughout their project work the better prepared they will be for the fair day. Consider having students do presentation practice games – i.e., read aloud in small groups, set a spinner for the speed you should talk, practice cadence. You can also encourage students to listen to news or informative podcasts (from reputable sources), radio broadcasts, etc. What are the features of professional speaking that stand out, and why?
Doing the Experiment: In this phase, students will proceed with their APPROVED experimentation or design. This includes gathering materials, following a timeline, allowing for adjustments, organizing data collection, and conducting data analysis. Adult support can be a critical resource in this phase. Resources in this section include guides for data analysis and suggestions for periodic check-ins with students.
The duration of this phase will vary depending on the approved experiment. Some projects, such as those involving plant growth, may require extended data collection. On average, students should expect this phase to take approximately 2 to 4 weeks.
If you haven’t yet, set up regular check-ins with students to make sure they are on the right track with their work. This can be critical to maintain timelines, but also to make sure students are working independently and feel empowered. Check-ins can be in person, or you can have students turn in or submit their responses for your review.
Use a check-in framework like this, modify as needed. You can also use the guidance below.
Even students who are working with outside sponsors for their project should have a check-in with teachers to make sure there is a mutual understanding of the work and emphasis on student learning.
Once projects are approved, students can gather supplies and place orders.
If your project requires a revision of materials or scope of work, you may need to request re-approval. Reach out if you’re not sure.
Some schools are eligible to receive support from MSEF for project supplies. Email info@scifair.com to learn more.
Begin experimentation and prototype construction, recording your data and process in your lab notebook
Use this guidance for recording work in your project notebook. (Coming soon)
While experimental error is a risk to the validity of a research project, it is not a safety hazard/risk (it does not need to be included in risk assessment paperwork, but it should be considered before beginning experimentation.)
During experimentation and design, students can make modifications to their procedure or materials within the scope of the approved project. Additional modifications can be emailed to src@scifair.com for reapproval if needed.
If there is not time or ability to adjust the work then it is important for students to remember that it is still an acceptable project if they disprove their hypothesis, weren’t able to complete enough tests, or were not successful in other ways. Being able to identify problems and articulate what they could have done differently shows judges that they have an understanding of their project area. Sometimes we actually learn more about the process and ourselves when things don’t go to plan. MSEF Alumni report that the mistakes they made in Middle School and High School projects helped them be stronger in STEM, both academically and professionally.
Students should statistically analyze their data as appropriate for their skillset. There is a wide range of possible approaches to take with data analysis based on project scope and student experience. Please guide them in this process and consider consulting other teachers for support if needed.
Students should
Use this Data Analysis Guide as a resource. (Google doc version can be found here.)
Once all experimentation is finished, make sure students have disposed of everything properly. Any excess materials should be taken care of safely (stored or disposed of) and approved of by your teacher or mentor.
Student reflection is important at this phase. This will improve their ability to show their critical thinking, independence, and resilience when speaking with judges about their work.
Consider assigning a thought exercise for students to record in their notebook.
You can also use the feedback prompts like those in the Student Project Planning Template for students to take part in peer-to-peer conversation, self-reflection, or teacher check-in.
Preparing for the Presentation: In this final phase, students will evaluate their process and results and develop the core materials for science fair participation. This includes ‘telling the story’ of their project through their written project report, the visual project display board, and the oral presentation. At the conclusion of this phase, students will participate in a school level, regional, state, or national/international fair.
This phase can start during the Explore phase as students start collecting their notes and findings. It continues the data analysis and data representation work.
Expect this phase to take 2 weeks, but can take longer with drafts and revisions.
Make sure all students are aware of the deadlines and deliverables they’ll need for the fair event — school fair, regional, and/or state.
Make sure you are keeping an eye on your emails for instructions from the regional or state fair about which students will participate and any necessary permissions or releases. Reach out to info@scifair.com if you haven’t received any information since messages sometimes get caught in SPAM filters.
Set incremental deadlines for drafts and review of the different components.
By having students map out their three final project components (oral, visual, paper) they will see where to duplicate effort – it’s not three completely different components! Slide 2 and 3 of the Project Component Guide provide an overview of the project components needed.
Keep these tips in mind as students prepare their project components
Project Reports do not need to be lengthy, potentially-publishable papers. Many judges prefer shorter documents (no more than 5 pages) that clearly demonstrate student projects and their ability to organize their work.
Remember this guidance for their project report and consider working with other staff or faculty in the school to support student writing practice.
Engineering Project Report and Science Project Report guides are available.
Exemplars can be found here
Project Report assessment rubric (coming soon)
A short summary of the project is similar to an abstract which is common in scientific papers. MSEF requests submission of this project description so we can learn more about your project. At the High School level the abstracts are shared with judges and compiled into a booklet at the State Fair.
Submission to zFairs will ask for a project description. While students may have included a draft of your project early on, make sure they finalize the language before the fair according to instructions and deadlines provided.
We encourage listing KEYWORDS so the important topics or fields of study can ‘jump out’ on a search of abstracts. For example, keywords may be highlighting big topics like ‘Women’s Health; Clean Energy; Endangered Species; Cancer; Machine Learning.”
A students project display is designed to help to add impact and aid understanding to their project. Emphasize:
This should be a physical, visual display students will use for their presentation- typically a tri-fold board. It can be professionally printed or patched together from several print outs- both are acceptable.
More suggestions for formatting and display can be found in here.
Sample display boards and general formatting visuals can be found here.
Exemplars can be found here.
This is the 5-8 minute ‘pitch’ about your project, plus the Q&A with judges. Students don’t have much time so need to stay focused and not to try to cover too every detail.
Review these tips to prepare and practice the presentation.
Make sure they review the judging rubrics for their grade so that they know what judges will be looking for in their presentation. This will help them focus on where to spend their time and what to be sure to mention. For example in both rubrics student independence is 10 points out of 100.
Make sure students review what is allowed at the Fair event (safety rules are available in both Manuals). There are restrictions on bringing electrical components, water, and other devices or materials.
Students should write a packing list as they prepare for the event so they don’t forget anything last minute if they are rushing.
And students should be reminded often to enjoy this work! This is the celebration of their work. They should get to know the students around them and not see them as competitors but as other students who have some exciting work to share.
| Thank you to National Grid for their support of the Science Fair Ready Teacher Toolkit
|
Thank you to the following educators for their contributions to the 2025 Science Fair Ready Toolkit. Kristen Mancini, Annie Poirier, Jonathan Rymasz, Mus, Molly, Latasha Sheffield, Haneen Saleh, Preetha Vijayakumar
|
Learn more about Fair dates, regions, paperwork, and eligibility.